From My Bookshelf: An Insider’s Guide to Creative Writing Programs

This review originally appeared in the January 2007 issue of The Writer magazine.

Help for Choosing a Writing Program

An Insider’s Guide to Creative Writing Programs: Choosing the Right MFA or MA Program, Colony, Residency, Grant, or Fellowship
by Amy Holman, Prentice-Hall Press/Penguin, 208 pages plus CD-ROM. Paperback, $18.95

Review by Erika Dreifus

If you’re tired of Googling for online lists of MFA programs or writing grants or residencies, and if you’re not interested in seeking separate print volumes dedicated to each of the same, Amy Holman’s new book, An Insider’s Guide to Creative Writing Programs will make you very happy. A published poet and literary consultant who indeed demonstrates an insider’s knowledge of the field, Holman has assembled a no-nonsense guide to several key aspects of writers’ professional development. Both beginners and more advanced writers should be grateful.

Holman defines “creative writing programs” broadly; she wants to “open your minds to possibilities you might have overlooked, thought were closed to you, or worried were too hard to pursue, and to change your mind about them.” So she doesn’t limit herself to academic (MA or MFA) programs in creative writing–although she profiles 60 such programs, including some administered through the popular low-residency option, in the book, and lists another 93 on the accompanying CD-ROM. She covers residencies, colonies, grants, and fellowships, too.

The book’s first sections introduce you to this vocabulary and offer advice on “choosing the right program at the right time” and preparing an application. Holman provides the context, background and guidance for you to proceed on your own, because, as she rightly notes, “How you become encouraged about your writing ability, how you improve, hone, or perfect it depends largely on your personality and also on your personal engagement to the literary community to date.” She wants to help you identify the “right environments” for your own development as a writer; she understands that that will be a personal process.

Program profiles fill most of the book. Those covering graduate schools (presented alphabetically, as Holman has wisely avoided ranking them) stand out for the way they highlight distinguishing features/program “perks” while following an economical and easy-to-follow template: For each program, Holman tells you what kind of degree it offers, a “nutshell” summary, a faculty list, and information on “defraying the cost.” Non-academic program descriptions are similarly highly individualized. Holman also does the reader a favor by signaling when colonies or grants are truly open to early-career writers and when they’re really looking for very experienced, very published people. Holman complements the listings with informative quotations throughout.

Since Holman limited the number of profiles printed in the book (which keeps the text both readable and portable), one of An Insider’s Guide to Creative Writing Programs‘s selling points is its accompanying CD-ROM, “with listings and links for 300 programs.” This bonus sounds fantastic, and in many ways it is (especially in listing and linking programs located outside the United States). But take note of my experience:

*I could not initially access the promised searchable database on my Mac; when I tried the disc on a library PC, that problem seemed to disappear.

*The desktop left me confused. I didn’t know which file/icon to click; I would have appreciated a file labeled “Read me first.” When I did find the database, I learned that I could search only one category at a time (type of program, state, or subject of program).

*Although I searched successfully for “low-residency MA programs,” an attempt to identify “low-residency MFA programs” yielded what seemed to be a list of residency and low-residency programs combined.

*Similarly, the 300 promised programs are divided among multiple categories (Resident MA; Resident MFA; Low-Residency MFA; Low-Residency MA; Artist Colonies and Writers Colonies; Artist-in-Residence Programs in National Parks and Community; Academic Writer-in-Residence Programs; Grants and Fellowships; and Paid Writing Spaces). Holman provides an excellent introduction, but to identify additional programs you’ll still need to make use of other resources (including those helpfully linked in a “Resources” section).

*If you’re hoping that the CD-ROM will contain program descriptions similar to those Holman provides in the book, be forewarned that it offers program links only. In other words, you won’t find another 93 MA/MFA program descriptions there.

Those observations notwithstanding, Holman has done something exceedingly useful here. “No matter at what stage–beginning, emerging, or established–you are in your writing career, you have goals,” Holman writes. An Insider’s Guide to Creative Writing Programs will help you meet them.

Friday Find: Off the Shelf

I haven’t yet taken the time to introduce “Off the Shelf,” a blog from the Boston Globe that I recently added to the links on the side of this page. It’s a great resource for writers and readers in the Boston area, since it includes updated listings of local author appearances. And it’s a great resource for anyone like me, recently transplanted from Beantown, who misses reading familiar names like David Mehegan and Jan Gardner on matters book-related. It even has some features I haven’t yet explored (such as a discussion board).

Options for Book Reviews and Book Reviewers

For those of you who may have missed it the first time, here’s my feature article from the June 2007 issue of The Practicing Writer.

OPTIONS FOR BOOK REVIEWS AND BOOK REVIEWERS

I love newspapers. As someone who was born in Brooklyn, New York, and raised there and in nearby New Jersey, I often feel as though I grew up with The New York Times. I certainly remained attached enough to the Times to maintain a subscription while also subscribing to The Washington Post when I lived in DC and to the Globe for the many years I lived in the Boston area. I’ll confess that I’ve never had occasion to read or subscribe to the Atlanta Journal-Constitution (AJC), so I’ve had no legitimate reason to add my signature to the petition you may have heard about recently, asking the AJC to maintain its stand-alone book section–and to keep it under a specific longtime editor’s control.

Newspapers have been facing struggles for quite awhile now. And book sections aren’t isolated in their suffering. Sure, I’ve had editors responsible for book coverage tell me they couldn’t take a review pitch because space was too tight. But other section editors have said exactly the same thing, responding to other article queries. Sometimes my accepted work has been delayed (and delayed) before finally being published thanks, I’ve been told, to those very same space constraints.

But rumors of the demise of the book review are, I think, at least somewhat exaggerated. I’m not ready to buy into the gloom and doom scenario quite yet. For one thing, I don’t believe that all the new strategies newspapers are trying–like combining book coverage with opinion writing and/or other arts and culture writing–are quite so catastrophic as some people have suggested. I don’t remember how many years ago the Globe created a hybrid “Ideas” section for Sundays; I think we all weathered that change pretty well. After all, some of us believe that ideas rest at the heart of the very best books; it’s a natural combination.

Maybe I’m also not quite so demoralized by shrinking book review pages in certain Sunday newspapers because, frankly, I uncover a lot of good book coverage elsewhere. As a reader–and as a book reviewer–I find encouragement and inspiration in the many magazines, literary journals, Web sites, and various “niche” publications that also provide good discussion of books, authors, and writing. Beyond that, I frequently see books reviewed and authors profiled in “other” newspaper sections (think about travel-related books you’ve seen covered in travel sections, food-related titles in food/dining sections, and so on).

But what if you’re an aspiring or veteran book reviewer who has been alarmed enough by the recent coverage of the need to “save the book review” to believe that the end is, in fact, dangerously near? Where can you look?

Let’s take two examples. Let’s consider two new books and think about their possible coverage outside Sunday newspaper book reviews.

This month Random House will release Connie Schultz’s …and His Lovely Wife: A Memoir from the Woman Beside the Man. Schultz, who won a 2005 Pulitzer for Commentary, is married to the junior United States Senator from Ohio, Sherrod Brown. The book is essentially her memoir of Brown’s most recent campaign.

Now, maybe the Atlanta Journal-Constitution will no longer be able to review this book. And quite possibly Schultz’s own paper, The Cleveland Plain Dealer, shouldn’t. So where else might you reasonably expect to find the book discussed/reviewed?

I’d look to regional magazines (in this case, those focusing on Ohio). Or Schultz’s alumni magazine (she’s a 1979 graduate of Kent State University). Or magazines or Web sites that focus on American politics.

I’d also think about venues especially interested in promoting women’s writing, and/or interested in issues relating to marriage and family. And let’s not forget that given Schultz’s journalistic accomplishments and prominence, “trade” publications (American Journalism Review, for starters) might be relevant, too.

Are you starting to see the possibilities?

Now let’s turn to the second example. If you read my blog regularly, you know there’s a new poetry book at the top of my to-be-read stack right now. Third Temple (University of Tampa Press) is the latest volume by Richard Chess, who is both a creative writing professor and director of the Jewish Studies program at the University of North Carolina-Asheville.

Since both print and online literary journals can be particularly hospitable to poetry reviews, I’ll hope to see Third Temple reviewed widely in such venues. Thinking regionally again, I’ll hope that publications in North Carolina will cover it. And given the particularly Jewish content of these poems, I’ll also hope to see magazines, newspapers, and Web sites that focus on Jewish themes and subjects featuring this new book (for just a few examples: Nextbook.org, JBooks.com, and The Forward).

So no matter what you’re hearing, don’t succumb to despair quite yet. You can still do your part to sustain serious thinking and reading and writing about books, even if you have to do it outside the Sunday newspaper book review sections. You may have to think a little more creatively, and do a little more research. But if you really want to read about books, and write about them, and expand others’ literary awareness, you still can.

(c) 2007 Erika Dreifus

Erika Dreifus, author of The Practicing Writer’s Directory of Paying Markets for Book Reviewers, has published dozens of book reviews in venues as varied as the Boston Globe Sunday travel section, the Christian Science Monitor, Community College Week, JBooks.com, The Missouri Review, Our State, The Writer magazine, and The Chattahoochee Review, where she is a contributing editor.

From My Bookshelf: Reading Like a Writer

The original version of this review appeared in The Writer Magazine, February 2007.

Reading Like a Writer: A Guide for People Who Love Books and for Those Who Want to Write Them
by Francine Prose, HarperCollins, 288 pages.
Hardcover, $23.95 (also available in paperback as of April 2007, $13.95)

We hear it all the time: If you want to be a writer, read. And don’t just skim, or read for plot, or race through to a story’s end. Read in a special way. Read closely. Read like a writer.

But what does that really mean? How does one read for lessons on craft and technique, lessons that can hopefully be transferred from Flaubert’s or Tolstoy’s pages to one’s own? It’s an essential art for any serious writer, but it can be an extraordinarily elusive one. Fortunately, Francine Prose, herself the author of 14 books of fiction, has given us a guide to her own “education as a novelist” that truly does, as she intends, “help the passionate reader and would-be writer understand how a writer reads.”

Other writers and writing instructors may talk about “close reading,” but Prose actually shows us how it’s done. Again and again, she provides excerpts from published work followed by her own analysis. She looks at words; she looks at sentences; she looks at the language within the dialogue. For Prose, these are the concepts that really matter: she notes that “to talk about sentences is to have a conversation about something far more meaningful and personal to most authors than the questions they’re more often asked, such as, Do you have a work schedule? Do you use a computer? Where do you get your ideas?”

So talk about sentences (and words, paragraphs, dialogue, narration, and much more) Prose does. In neatly divided chapters, she takes on all the true tools of the writer’s craft and shows us how others have used them to maximum effect. She gives us, for example, the first lines of the first six paragraphs in Stendhal’s The Red and the Black, showing how the author “introduc[es] the reader to the topography of the town before narrowing in on one of its inhabitants.” She also gives us that novel’s entire fifth paragraph, “because it is such an elegant example of its form, one of those single paragraphs in which a writer tells us nearly all we need to know about a character.”

Stendhal is no accidental selection. Reading Prose’s examples, as well as following her suggested “List of Books to Be Read Immediately,” you’ll be considering many “classic” authors. Although she highlights some contemporary writers, including Gary Shteyngart and ZZ Packer, her texts of reference come primarily from the canonical past, for which she (refreshingly) makes no apologies: “You can assume that if a writer’s work has survived for centuries there are reasons why this is so, explanations that have nothing to do with a conspiracy of academics plotting to resuscitate a zombie army of dead white males.” Prose even devotes an entire chapter to “Learning from Chekhov.”

At the same time, Prose is careful to point out how often traditions–in the form of familiar writing mantras and “rules”–can and have been broken. Citing an Alice Munro excerpt, for instance, she encourages us to think how much more powerful “telling” can be, when we’re usually directed to “show.” Later, when she notes that one-sentence paragraphs “can be an annoying tic, a lazy writer’s attempt to compel us to pay attention or to inject energy and life into a narrative,” Prose also provides examples (Herman Melville’s “Bartleby the Scrivener” and Raymond Carver’s “Fat”) “in which single sentences actually do seem to merit paragraphs of their own.”

An experienced teacher, Prose also anticipates difficulties newer writers encounter: “Even when novice writers avoid the sort of dialogue that is essentially exposition framed by quotation marks, the dialogue they do write often serves a single purpose–that is, to advance the plot–rather than the numerous simultaneous aims that it can accomplish.” Then she provides counterexamples that instruct, illustrate and inspire (in this case, excerpts, sometimes lengthy, from novels by Henry Green).

“I’ve always thought that a close-reading course should at least be a companion, if not an alternative, to the writing workshop,” Prose muses. For those not lucky enough to enroll in such a course with Francine Prose, Reading Like a Writer is an excellent (not to mention relatively inexpensive) substitute.

Housekeeping

Faithful blog visitors–and I know there are a few of you out there!–may be noticing some “redecorating” here at the blog, with new sidebars for book reviews and author interviews. I suppose one personal side effect of all the recent brouhaha over a “book reviewing crisis” has been a renewed motivation to try to archive more of my reviews online. So look for some blasts from the past (I’ll try to keep everything relatively recent) to appear here in the coming days/weeks.