This is a text that our family rabbi sent to the congregation earlier today. I am reprinting it here with his permission.
Dear Congregational Family:
I always feel the need to write when something so complicated and confusing is happening in Israel.
The events of this past weekend were tragic on one hand and have unfortunately led to hastened condemnation by the world community on the other. As you know, I am an avid Zionist and speak steadfastly in support of our spiritual Homeland. However, I have also told you many times that I feel comfortable speaking out against policy when I feel it is the right thing to do. In this case, I am outraged that before any investigation has had the chance to take place, the world has found its way to instant censure of Israel.
Unfounded facts are being so swiftly flung in our direction, that it is hard to formulate a coherent defense of what took place two days ago. Thus, I am attaching what I think is extremely helpful information which will fill many of the details, as well as help all of us be able to engage in an educated dialogue with facts in hand.
The following information provided by Arza. Arza is the Association of Reform Zionists of America – the Zionist arm and voice of the Reform Movement in the United States – it endeavors to make Israel fundamental to the sacred lives and Jewish identity of Reform Jews. As a Zionist organization, ARZA champions activities that further enhance Israel as a pluralistic, just and democratic Jewish state.
As you can tell from the description, Arza claims no political affiliation, nor does it lobby any political party. This is in fact not a time to take a political position. This is the time for Jews to come together in solidarity for Israel.
Please take the time to read the below statement.
Rabbi Matthew D. Gewirtz
ARZA Statement on the Gaza Flotilla Incident
June 1, 2010
On May 31, the day when Americans paused to remember those who have fallen in battle, we woke to the difficult news that early that morning Israeli commandos had stopped six ships carrying hundreds of pro-Palestinian activists on an aid mission to Gaza. Five of the ships calmly complied with the stoppage. The sixth ship did not. It was on this sixth vessel, the Turkish registered Mavi Marmara, where nine people were killed and dozens were wounded after IDF forces encountered unexpected resistance from civilians wielding knives, crow bars and small arms. Turkey’s NTV showed activists beating one Israeli soldier with sticks as he rappelled from a helicopter onto one of the boats. Another soldier was thrown from an upper deck of one of the ships and then stomped on by activists.
The Israeli military said troops only opened fire after the activists attacked them with knives and iron rods, and one activist wrested a serviceman’s weapon. Two of the dead activists had fired at soldiers with pistols, the army said. Organizers included people affiliated with the International Solidarity Movement, a pro-Palestinian group that often sends international activists into battle zones, and the IHH, a Turkish aid group that Israel accuses of having terrorist links.
Though the flotilla was in international waters at the time of the attack, Israel has operated under an international law that allows a state, during a time of conflict, to enforce an embargo in international waters. Within this framework, it is legal for civilian ships to be stopped if they are trying to break the embargo.
It would appear that this entire enterprise was a cynical set-up designed to present Israel with an unnecessary Hobson’s choice and to generate anti-Israel publicity.
As so often happens after incidents such as this one, foreign governments were quick to condemn Israel for excessive use of force without full facts. Editorials in Israel note a mixed reaction to the Government’s action while still all affirming the right of sovereign self defense. The government of Israel has responded that Israel has the right to blockade Gaza ports to prevent weapons from entering that area and that Israeli Navy personnel were prepared to deal with protesters, not people armed with knives, crowbars and other weapons.
ARZA expresses its sorrow at the loss of life and expresses the hope that all those injured will soon recover from their wounds. ARZA further expresses the hope that governments and individuals will not rush to judgment but will wait for all the facts to emerge before coming to any conclusion. As is so often the case when dealing with incidents that occur in a very unsettled part of the world, it is often difficult to ascertain the facts but very easy to jump to conclusions.
Our sacred task is to build an ever stronger progressive religious presence in Israel. Even when Israel is experiencing difficult moments like these, we must remain focused on creating facts on the ground. To the extent that ARZA can support IMPJ and IRAC, their work will enlarge the societal conversation on Judaism and the creation of a just, democratic, and Jewish Israel.
While waiting for a full report on what happened today, there are some facts that are already clear:
· The flotilla was organized by an Islamist organization that has links to fundamentalist jihadi groups.
· Israel offered from the first announcement of the flotilla that it or the Red Cross would deliver any humanitarian aid to Gaza, as it does daily.
· The extremists brought small children on board by persons hoping to provoke what could be a violent confrontation,
· The activists were carrying 10,000 tons of what they said was aid. Israel transfers about 15,000 tons of supplies and humanitarian aid every week to the people of Gaza.
· “We fully intend to go to Gaza regardless of any intimidation or threats of violence against us, they are going to have to forcefully stop us,” said one of the flotilla’s organizers.
· Using the Arabic term ‘intifada,’ Hamas spokesman Sami Abu Zuhri said “We call on all Arabs and Muslims to rise up in front of Zionist embassies across the whole world.
· Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh said this week: “If the ships reach Gaza it is a victory; if they are intercepted, it will be a victory too.
· Israel left Gaza in hopes of peace in 2005 and in return received more than 8,000 rockets and terrorist attacks.
· No country would allow illegal entry of any vessel into their waters without a security check.
(NB from Erika: The ARZA statement is available for downloading on the ARZA site, and includes a long list of recommended weblinks that I have not reprinted here.)