Words of the Week

“I recognize that there are those people, on the right and on the left, for whom their relationship to Israel is not just a moral imperative but an exclusive imperative; and for whom, therefore, common cause with an opponent issue entails transgressing an impassable line. I respect this position, especially in its self-awareness of its hierarchy of moral choices. But I also believe it is a tragic position to take in a political moment that requires of us commitments to more than one moral imperative; and also because I wonder whether our willingness to work with outspoken critics of Israel right now, when we agree on many other issues, may in fact enable us to manage those tensions with those critics more effectively in the long run. I think a David Ben-Gurion-like position is a perfectly tenable moral position that balances multiple moral imperatives: We fight for our moral values in American political life as though there was no disagreement with our allies on these issues on Israel, and we fight on Israel with critics of Israel as though there was no domestic agenda. The existence of multiple moral frameworks with which to view the world is not a sign of confusion; it is a sign of sophistication and strength.”

Food for thought (for me, at any rate.)

Source: Yehuda Kurtzer, “Linda Sarsour and American Jewish Politics” (Jewish Journal)

One thought on “Words of the Week

  1. Doug Hile says:

    Kurtzer makes some sense, and his conclusion is laudable, however, (and this may be over-simplification), the fact remains; Israel, and the Jewish People specifically, are Gods Chosen People. Their history is a miracle of triumph against overwhelming odds and they have more than earned their survival, they deserve it. To face the mindless hordes now singularly bent on their destruction, and to show the restraint Israel is showing, is nothing less than God-like. Any moral human being regardless of religion, or completely devoid of it, cannot look the present condition and not feel sympathy, if not an urge to help. I have no doubt that Israel will solve this dilemma. I hope it will be soon. The world will be better for it. Israel should not have to do it alone.

Comments are closed.