Creative Writing at CUNY

If you’re in the New York City area, please do visit this list of literary events taking place on the various campuses of The City University of New York. (As you know, I’m a CUNY employee, and part of my job includes updating this list.) And if you’re looking for some low-cost, high-quality writing programs (undergraduate, graduate, and certificate), please consult this page as well. (P.S.–You’ll find my latest CUNY Distinguished Professor Profile, this time focusing on art historian and biographer Gail Levin, right here.)

The Wednesday Web Browser: Styron Revisited, MFA Event in New York, and My Other Blog

It’s no secret to this blog’s readers that I’m a fan of the work of William Styron. Which is why I was particularly interested to find Jess Row’s essay, “Styron’s Choice,” revisiting a literary controversy from the late 1960s.
==========
If you’re in the New York area and thinking about an MFA, you might want to check out this event, slated for tomorrow night and featuring Kimiko Hahn, Distinguished Professor in the Queens College-CUNY MFA Program, and Robert Polito, who directs the Writing Program at The New School. ($5 “suggested donation”)
==========
Don’t forget to check in once in awhile over on my other blog, where I focus on literature, culture, and, occasionally, politics with a distinctly Jewish emphasis. The most recent post discusses the fabulous, don’t-miss film “A Secret” (“Un Secret”), based on Philippe Grimbert’s roman à clef.

Ten Ways to Tick Me Off in a Writing Workshop

(This article originally appeared in the August 2008 issue of our free monthly newsletter, The Practicing Writer.)

TEN WAYS TO TICK ME OFF IN A WRITING WORKSHOP

By Erika Dreifus

As most of you know, I’ve recently returned from a writing workshop. Within our group of six, I established what promise to be two lasting friendships. And I am quite positive that I made one lifelong enemy.

In my history attending conference and MFA workshops, I’ve usually managed to complete each session having connected with at least one other writer I can still call a friend (and a reader) even years later. But truth be told, I’m pretty sure I’ve also earned the eternal dislike of at least one classmate each go-round as well.

“You’re a tough critic, Erika!” my most recent instructor observed last month. And it’s true. I am a tough critic. I’m especially “tough” when the workshop I’m participating in is billed as an MFA workshop, or a Master Class. Then, my expectations, both for the level of critique and the quality of the manuscripts, are ratcheted up. (I’m a demanding teacher, too, but I won’t get into that here, except to paraphrase semi-disgruntled remarks on student evaluations, such as: “Sometimes it seemed as though Erika actually wanted us to live up to the same high standards she has for herself.” Guilty as charged.)

Anyway, my most recent experience led me to think back to previous workshops I’ve enrolled in. It sparked reflections on the aspects of workshops I’ve most loathed in the 15 years or so I’ve taken part in them. And so this month, I share with you “Ten Ways to Tick Me Off in a Writing Workshop.”

1) Submit a piece that exceeds the page limits the instructor has delineated. Especially if you’re distributing your piece on site, at the conference or the residency, and I have to squeeze in my reading between all the other scheduled activities. Chances are I wouldn’t even want to read “extra” Flaubert in that situation! NB: Managing to avoid submitting a piece that exceeds the page limits only by “adjusting” the line spacing and margins isn’t going to make me happy, either.

2) Accompany the manuscript with a full-page, single-spaced autobiography, revealing that every instance of mistreatment your fictional protagonist has suffered is, in fact, grounded in the truth of your own harsh childhood. On a personal level, I’ll be very sorry for your suffering. But this is a writing workshop. It isn’t group therapy.

3) Riddle the manuscript you submit for group review with errors of spelling, punctuation, and syntax. If you want to give me reasons to become frustrated as I read through your text, and to be completely distracted from whatever story you are trying to tell, go right ahead. But you probably won’t appreciate my commenting on your problems with standard English in the critique.

4) Repeat, every single time you open your mouth, that what you’re about to say around the workshop table “is just my opinion.” Of course it’s your opinion! Who else might you be speaking for? And isn’t everything we offer in a workshop “opinion”? It’s true that some of us have more informed and insightful opinions than others. But every time you preface your remarks with this kind of “disclaimer,” you help ensure that I won’t count yours among them.

5) Scrawl illegible comments all over the manuscript. Believe me, I know what it is to have terrible handwriting. Which is why I type up comments for each manuscript I critique.

6) Tell me what YOU “want” or “would like to see” in my manuscript (or, for that matter, in anyone else’s manuscript). It’s astonishing but true: Writing workshops are supposed to be about MANUSCRIPTS. About what each writer is trying to accomplish in her manuscript, and how it succeeds in meeting that intent. It’s NOT an exercise in getting someone else to write a story YOU “would like” to see written. Here’s a hint: Some of the most successful critiques I’ve received rarely used the word “I.” They were not about what the reader “wanted,” but rather focused on what she found in the manuscript, what seemed confusing or inconsistent. I’ve come to try to reduce the first person pronoun in my own critiques, too.

7) Tell me that since you are a mother, you know how my mother characters should be portrayed a lot better than I do. (For a detailed discussion of this particular peeve, click here).

8) Tell me that I should dumb down my manuscript simply because you don’t have any familiarity with the subject or setting it treats (and likely wouldn’t choose to read a book that dealt with it anyway). This has happened to me many times, particularly in pieces of historical fiction connected with World War II and the Holocaust, and in writing on Jewish themes more generally. I will never forget my disbelief (and, to be frank, outrage) when it became clear that one of my classmates thought I’d invented not only the “character” of Israeli Prime Minister Golda Meir, but also the entire massacre of Israeli athletes at the 1972 Munich Olympics, and thought I should add “explanations” throughout my story accordingly (that story, minus any “explanations,” later won the David Dornstein Memorial Creative Writing Contest for writing on Jewish themes).

9) Return my manuscript without any mark-up whatsoever. Without any written critique. Especially when I’ve devoted my time and energy to yours.

10) Return my manuscript (with or without mark-up and comments) late. Or fail to return my manuscript at all.

Yes, I’ve managed to alienate a certain segment of nearly every workshop I’ve participated in. But I’ve remained true to my standards and myself, and I’ve somehow managed to collect a cluster of creative writing soulmates in the process. You can’t please all the people all the time, as an author. Or in a workshop. But it is possible to please me!

Guest Post from a New MFA Student

I am happy to present this guest post from Deonne Kahler, who is about to begin the MFA adventure here in New York (at Queens College of The City University of New York). Please check back for a follow-up post from Deonne once her program gets underway. Enjoy!

A Fifth Reason to Go to Grad School? All the Ramen I Can Eat!

by Deonne Kahler

When I tell people I’m about to start an MFA program they say, Gee Deonne, you’ve already accumulated hundreds of clips (the result of writing for newspapers for seven years) so you must know how to string words together. Why the heck do you want to spend the money and time on a degree that might not increase your writing income one iota? (Question: is my use of the word “iota” further proof I don’t need an MFA?) And don’t you think you could just spend more time in bars (a la Hemingway, but without that nasty suicide business) and gather material that way? Don’t you think you should skip the academics, live life, and just write?

That’s perfectly fine advice, and I must admit it’s tempting to have a legitimate reason to spend more time in bars. But then I’d probably just end up writing some sad chronicle of my years battling alcoholism, involving overuse of the words “vomit,” “rock bottom,” and “rehab,” and lord knows we have enough of those.

The “just write” part is legitimate if you either feel like you already have a good grasp on craft, or you don’t and are prepared to learn by doing a lot of self-directed reading and writing. But if you’re anything like me that could take a long time, meaning, I’m a world-class procrastinator – I’m the Michael Phelps of procrastination. (Question: isn’t my willingness to use lame metaphors proof I do need an MFA?)

My reasons for going to grad school:

1. Focused, structured study of the art and craft of writing. I’ve yet to find a bartender who offered me a reading list, deadlines and critique.
2. A ready-made community of writers, both fledgling (students) and accomplished (faculty).
3. The chance to work on a literary journal (QC’s Ozone Park). This in tandem with my internship at The Feminist Press should give me excellent publishing and editorial experience.
4. Because I can. I’ve got the savings (for awhile, anyway), I’m entirely unencumbered, and I really, really, really want to do this. ‘Nuff said.

There’s only one thing I’m anxious about: grades. My undergrad experience in that department was, ahem, less than stellar, and I’m already anxious about that first grad school report card, because I’m pretty sure if it’s bad my parents will ground me. Other than that, I’m psyched for the experience. Like Michael Phelps before a race. (Somebody stop me.)

Here’s what I hope to accomplish at Queens:

1. Become a better writer. Duh.
2. Complete a manuscript. Whether that will be a novel or memoir remains to be seen, and I’m giving myself the first semester to decide. We don’t technically have to start our thesis (the manuscript) until second year, but I’m a slow writer and get anxious if I don’t have enough time to do something I care about. So I’m planning to start early.
3. Develop a daily writing practice. Up until now my non-freelance writing has been haphazard at best. I believe great writers are born from hard work and regular practice (how very Calvinist!), and since I do want to be great, or at least extra good, I’ll need the discipline of regular writing to carry me beyond the structure of grad school.

That’s where I’m at. I’ll keep you posted on how it’s going, but if you don’t hear from me it means I sent home a terrible report card and am on restriction until I get my grades up, and I’d better quit my crying or I’ll really have something to cry about. Wish me luck.

The Wednesday Web Browser: Murray State MFA, My Other Blog, and a New Poet Laureate

Dan Wickett tells us about his visit to the Murray State University low-res MFA program during its latest residency session.
==========
Just a reminder for those of you who may be particularly interested in Jewish-themed writing, writers, publishers, and publications: my other blog has a much more Jewishly-focused perspective. For example, yesterday I added a post on Alana Newhouse’s move from The Forward to Nextbook, and one about an upcoming event in New York City featuring Sami Rohr Prize winner Tamar Yellin.
==========
And in case you haven’t yet heard, we have a new Poet Laureate here in the USA: Kay Ryan. Read the Library of Congress press release here.